To the Ichikawa Municipal Government, Zoo and Botanical Gardens Division,

We write to urge you to take decisive, compassionate action on behalf of Punch, the young Japanese macaque currently housed at Ichikawa City Zoo.

Punch’s story has drawn global attention because it reveals something deeper than a viral moment. Born during extreme summer heat and rejected by his mother shortly after birth, he has faced early developmental challenges without the maternal guidance that is essential in macaque society. His reliance on a plush toy for comfort is not entertainment. It is a visible sign of unmet attachment needs.

Reintegration into a strict matrilineal troop without maternal protection places Punch at a structural disadvantage. Japanese macaque hierarchies are complex and unforgiving. Without a mother to buffer aggression and model appropriate social cues, an orphaned infant can struggle to establish secure standing. While some level of discipline is natural in primate groups, repeated stress during formative months can carry lasting psychological consequences.

We respectfully request that Punch be evaluated for transfer to an accredited primate sanctuary specializing in rehabilitation and social integration for vulnerable macaques. A true sanctuary environment—one that prioritizes spacious naturalistic habitats, reduced public exposure, stable peer group formation, and trauma-informed care—would offer him a stronger chance to develop social competence without the pressures of exhibition and viral attention.

Sanctuaries exist to provide lifelong, species-appropriate care to animals who have experienced early disruption. Unlike traditional zoo settings, their mission centers on welfare over display. Punch deserves an environment designed first and foremost for healing, safety, and long-term well-being.

This request is rooted not in outrage, but in humanity. Compassion asks us to look beyond what is customary and consider what is optimal. When an animal’s vulnerability becomes visible to the world, we have an opportunity to respond with moral clarity. Punch is not a symbol or attraction. He is a sentient primate navigating loss, stress, and social uncertainty.

By transferring Punch to a sanctuary equipped to meet his complex needs, your division can demonstrate leadership in animal welfare and set a meaningful precedent for ethical stewardship.

Taking this step will affirm that empathy and science can guide policy. It will show that public institutions can evolve in response to new understanding. And it will help ensure a better future for Punch and for all animals entrusted to human care.

Sincerely,