In a surprising and controversial decision, Iceland's government granted a whale hunting license to the country's last remaining whaling company, Hvalur hf., for the 2024 season.

The permit allows for the hunting of 128 fin whales, a move that has sparked significant backlash from animal welfare groups and conservationists alike.

This decision contrasts with recent global efforts aimed at protecting marine life and highlights the ongoing debate over the ethics and necessity of commercial whaling.

 

A Decline in Quotas But Continued Controversy

The granted quota for 2024 is lower than in previous years, with permission to hunt 99 fin whales in the waters around Greenland and West Iceland, and 29 around East Iceland and the Faroe Islands. Last year, the Icelandic government issued a quota for 161 fin whales, making this year's allocation a significant reduction, BBC News reports. However, this decrease has done little to quell the concerns of animal rights activists, who argue that any level of whaling is unacceptable.

Animal welfare organizations, including the Humane Society International, have condemned the decision. They cite an independent report by the Icelandic Food and Veterinary Authority that documented severe suffering among hunted whales, with some taking up to two hours to die. he report found that 41% of whales suffered for an average of 11.5 minutes before dying, a clear violation of Iceland's own Animal Welfare Act, according to Mongabay.

 

International and Domestic Reactions

The international community has expressed dismay over Iceland's decision. Critics argue that it undermines global conservation efforts and the International Whaling Commission's (IWC) moratorium on commercial whaling. Despite being a member of the IWC, Iceland continues to defy the organization's guidelines, operating under a reservation to the ban, the Associated Press reports.

Árni Finnsson of the Iceland Nature Conservation Association told Mongabay the decision was "not good, but not nearly as bad as it could have been," noting the reduction in the hunting quota.

Domestically, the decision has not been without controversy. A recent survey indicated that 51% of Icelanders oppose commercial whaling, reflecting a significant public shift towards the conservation of marine life, BBC News reports.

The declining domestic and international market for whale products further questions the economic rationale behind continuing this practice. Most of the whale meat from Iceland's hunts is exported to Japan, where demand has also waned in recent years, Oceanographic Magazine reports.

 

Impact on the Fin Whale Population

The fin whale, the second-largest animal on Earth, is listed as vulnerable by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN). Despite this, Iceland, along with Japan and Norway, continues to hunt these gentle giants. The decision to grant a new whaling permit raises concerns about the sustainability of the fin whale population in the North Atlantic, particularly as these whales face numerous threats, including climate change and ocean pollution, the Associated Press reports.

Experts argue that the continued hunting of fin whales is not only inhumane but also environmentally unsustainable.

Mark Simmonds, Director of Science at OceanCare, criticized Iceland's decision, calling it "a huge disappointment and a disaster for wildlife on an already damaged planet."

As OceanCare reports, he emphasized that whaling is unnecessary and unethical, urging Iceland to halt this practice.

 

The Future of Whaling in Iceland

The future of whaling in Iceland remains uncertain. While the current government has shown a willingness to continue the practice, increasing domestic opposition and dwindling international markets could eventually lead to a policy shift. The Icelandic government has previously suspended whaling due to animal welfare concerns, suggesting that future actions could further restrict or even ban the practice.

Conservationists hope that Iceland will join the growing list of countries that have turned away from whaling. As public awareness of the ethical and environmental implications of whaling increases, the pressure on Iceland's government to align with global conservation efforts is likely to grow.

The international community and animal welfare organizations continue to advocate for an end to whaling, emphasizing that these magnificent creatures should be protected, not hunted. Iceland's decision to grant a whaling license for the 2024 season has sparked widespread condemnation and highlighted the ongoing debate over commercial whaling.

As the world increasingly turns towards conservation and sustainable practices, the future of whaling in Iceland remains a contentious and closely watched issue.

Click below and take action for whales in Iceland!