Nearly twenty years after Pennsylvania promised to clean up its notorious dog breeding industry, neglect and abuse remain common behind kennel doors. A new wave of investigations paints a grim picture of dogs trapped in filth, suffering untreated medical issues, and dying in conditions that mock the intent of reform.

According to Lady Freethinker, between June 2021 and April 2025, more than 270 kennels across 36 counties were cited for illegal activity. Over half of those violations involved unsanitary or inhumane conditions. Even as state officials claimed progress, inspectors documented dogs confined in windowless sheds, their fur matted with urine, bowls overturned, and air thick with ammonia.

In one Cumberland County facility, temperatures soared above 103 degrees. Puppies lay panting in their own waste without clean water. In Lancaster County, a breeder allegedly drowned four sheepadoodle puppies in manure because their coat color made them unsellable. Despite the cruelty charge, the case remains unresolved — a sign of the systemic weakness at the heart of Pennsylvania’s oversight.

Reform Without Enforcement

Pennsylvania’s 2008 Dog Law reforms once made it a national model for animal welfare. The law was meant to increase cage sizes, require outdoor access, and ensure veterinary care. But enforcement has eroded with time. Budget cuts and dwindling staff have left state dog wardens overwhelmed. As MyChesCo reports, many kennels continue operating despite repeat violations — some after years of written warnings and minimal fines.

Even licensed facilities, supposedly compliant, routinely fail inspections. Inspectors found rusting enclosures, feces-caked floors, and ventilation systems that didn’t work. In Adams County, dogs were found in freezing sheds. In another case, a husky was left in near 90-degree heat with no relief. Yet most of these kennels remain open, shielded by lenient penalties and a culture of bureaucratic inertia.

The Horrible Hundred

Pennsylvania’s reputation among the nation’s worst puppy-mill states persists. In the 2025 “Horrible Hundred” report by Humane World for Animals, Pennsylvania ranked alongside Missouri, Ohio, and Iowa for the number of breeders cited by regulators. The report lists 11 Pennsylvania kennels with chronic violations — many operating for years despite repeated state intervention.

At Lucky Acres Kennel in Lititz, wardens found food and water contaminated with feces. In Narvon’s Sunrise Kennel, inspectors repeatedly ordered veterinary checks for dogs with “abnormal conditions.” In Kinzers, bowls were filled with dead flies and enclosures soaked with urine. One operation in Honey Brook, closed in 2010 for enforcement reasons, reopened two years later under a new name — and quickly began racking up violations again.

The Legislative Stalemate

Efforts to close the gaps have stalled. Advocates continue to press for passage of Victoria’s Law, a bill that would ban the sale of dogs, cats, and rabbits from commercial breeding mills in pet stores. Named after a German Shepherd who spent a decade confined to a breeding cage, the measure seeks to end the retail pipeline that keeps puppy mills profitable.

But opposition from agricultural lobbyists and breeders has slowed progress. Industry groups claim such measures unfairly punish responsible operators and could drive illegal breeding further underground. For advocates, that argument rings hollow. “No animal should have to endure such filthy, barren conditions while breeders profit from their misery,” said Lady Freethinker’s Nina Jackel, calling for stricter enforcement and meaningful penalties.

Behind the Promises

The same cycle repeats: citations, minimal fines, and new licenses issued to the same offenders. Each inspection photo — a dog trembling in filth, a matted coat hiding open sores — stands as evidence of a promise unkept.

For thousands of dogs across Pennsylvania, the law exists only on paper. Reform without enforcement is no reform at all. Until the state confronts its failure to act, its kennels will remain what they have long been — factories of suffering, hidden in plain sight.

Click below to make a difference.