Pet owners often trust their grief to professionals who promise dignity and care. For thousands across western Pennsylvania, that trust was shattered. Between 2021 and 2024, more than 6,500 families paid for private cremations and burials at Eternity Pet Memorial, only to learn that the animals they loved may have been dumped like trash.

Prosecutors say the man behind the operation, 70-year-old funeral director Patrick Vereb, pocketed over $650,000 in fees while returning ashes that were not from the pets entrusted to him.

The horror of the deception extends far beyond financial loss. For people like Brittany Cain, who used Eternity Pet Memorial twice for her pet rabbits, the emotional toll is staggering. She told WTAE, “It definitely destroys my faith in humanity a little more.”

Over 6,500 pet owners were deceived in Pennsylvania.

False Comfort, Real Damage

Vereb allegedly operated a dual-system: cremating only large dogs while disposing of smaller pets in landfills. The ashes returned to families were often a mix from other animals or, in some cases, of unknown origin. As former employee Tiffany Mantzouridis explained to CBS Pittsburgh, crematory tags were assigned inconsistently. Most pets under 30 pounds had no traceable ID. Larger dogs, which cost more to cremate, were incinerated and divided into smaller portions to simulate multiple private cremations.

Some ashes returned to grieving families came in Ziploc bags, unmarked and uncertified. Dawn Elder, whose cat Ava died in 2023, told CBS she opened her urn to find loose ashes with no identifying tag.

“I don’t know who or what remains I have,” she said.

Families paid for cremations but got fake ashes.

Broken Systems and Missed Warnings

The lack of oversight in Pennsylvania’s pet funeral industry made it easy for someone like Vereb to operate unchecked. Despite previous fraud convictions related to Medicare claims in the 1990s, which resulted in a suspended funeral license, he was still able to run both human and pet memorial services.

Funeral industry professionals expressed shock.

“It’s a sad reality of our business,” said Donna Shugart-Bethune of the International Association of Pet Cemeteries and Crematories, according to TribLIVE. She urged pet owners to ask about ID tracking systems and to insist on transparency from cremation providers.

Veterinary clinics who worked with Vereb have also been left reeling. Many were unaware that Eternity Pet Memorial was allegedly substituting ashes or failing to cremate pets altogether. Clinics like K Vet Animal Care in Hempfield reported an influx of calls from distraught clients once the news broke.

“Our team is fielding upset, sad, angry, confused, hurtful phone calls and emails,” manager Beth Zaccari told TribLIVE.

Grieving owners unknowingly memorialized the wrong remains.

Whistleblowers and Unanswered Questions

It was internal concerns that ultimately sparked the investigation. Mantzouridis, interning at Vereb’s facility in early 2024, documented black trash bags containing pet bodies left unrefrigerated in garages.

“There would be flies on them, and there would be blood everywhere and puddles,” she told CBS.

She began logging cremation records and noticed inconsistencies—dozens of pets were processed for services without crematory numbers. The math didn’t add up.

Invoices revealed the crematory only processed a small number of animals, yet customer spreadsheets suggested hundreds more had been serviced. Mantzouridis claims Vereb manipulated ashes behind closed doors, mixing remains and returning them without identification.

Pet aftercare is largely unregulated in Pennsylvania.

Grief Multiplied

The betrayal is personal and widespread. Pet owners like Brett Prior, who trusted a vet to arrange aftercare for his boxer, now feel blindsided.

“Unbeknownst to us, the company they were using was employing these tactics,” he told WTAE.

Others echoed his dismay, describing the second wave of grief brought on by the realization that they may have memorialized someone else’s animal—or nothing at all.

Even veterinary offices are reckoning with their role. Some, like Heart + Paw, immediately confirmed their current providers do not subcontract cremation services. “We checked with them this morning,” veterinarian Dr. Andrew Honigmann told TribLIVE. Others are still reviewing records to determine the scope of the damage.

Families deserve dignity, not deception, during loss.

Thousands Seek Answers

As the legal case unfolds, the Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General has launched a dedicated site for victims to provide information and receive updates. The site allows pet owners to check whether their vet contracted with Vereb and submit impact statements. According to The New York Times, at least 20 veterinary offices were involved.

Vereb is charged with theft by deception, receiving stolen property, and deceptive business practices. He was released pending a May court date. Investigators say the probe is ongoing.

Seeking Dignity in the Aftermath

The emotional weight of pet loss is profound. To exploit that grief for profit is, as Attorney General Dave Sunday put it, “devastating and disturbing.” While many crematories and funeral homes operate with integrity, this case highlights the need for stronger oversight, transparency, and compassion in an industry that handles what many consider to be family.

For families mourning twice—once for the pet they lost and again for the trust that was broken—no amount of justice will bring back the comfort they believed they received.

Click below to make a difference.